Pdf qhairs and nohair theorem for charged black holes. With the aid of bayesian model selection, we assess. Cosmic no hair theorems can be derived in different theoretical contexts and for a variety of models, including. Inotherwords,onecannothave anydeformationsofthehorizon. In this paper we examine the extent to which black hole quasinormal modes qnms could be used to test the no hair theorem with future ground and spacebased gravitationalwave detectors. In physics we refer to that complexity as the physical information of a system. This implies in particular that static black holes cannot possess dipole hair under these fields. The proof is very simple and based on a covariant method for generating solutions for nonminimally coupled scalar fields starting from the minimally coupled case. We provide strong numerical evidence for a new noscalarhair theorem for black holes in general relativity, which rules out spherical scalar hair of static four. Why its so impressive that fermats last theorem has been solved. Sep 17, 2019 just call it baldy fresh analysis of ligo data supports no hair theorem for black holes ringdown overtones yield accurate estimates of mass and spin of a new black hole.
Classical and quantum gravity, volume 12, number 2. The basic idea of the nohair theorem is that the material properties of any object referred to as hair because a. According to the no hair theorem, astrophysical black holes are uniquely characterized by their masses and spins and are described by the kerr metric. Nohair theorem for weak pulsar new york university. According to the nohair theorem of general relativity, static and isolated black holes can be fully characterized by just two numbers, the mass m and the angular momentum j.
Definition of black hole for the purposes of nohair theorems. Ev ery function of the same t yp e satis es the same theorem. The nohair theorem postulates that all black hole solutions of the einsteinmaxwell equations of gravitation and electromagnetism in general relativity can be completely characterized by only three externally observable classical parameters. The critical steps leading to the uniqueness theorem for the kerrnewman metric are reexamined in the light of the new black hole solutions with yangmills and scalar hair. The nohair theorem can be tested by measuring potential deviations from the kerr metric which.
The no hair theorem has not been proved for the yangmills field, but the only difference seems to be the addition of one or more integers that label a discrete family of unstable solutions. He shook his head and his hands moved up to his hair, pushing back his bangs and running through them slowly. Although the black holehasactuallyonehair,m,thispropertyisstillcalledthe nohair theorem and, thus, the black hole is called bald. For spherically symmetric manifolds m,g and riemannian manifolds n,g it is. The process of collapsing of a body to form a black hole can be a very complex and intriguing dynamic event. We consider implications of the quantum extension of the inflationary no hair theorem. Black hole thermodynamics says that the black hole entropy is proportional to the surface area of the event horizon. Pdf towards a novel nohair theorem for black holes semantic. A theorem postulating that all black hole solutions of the einsteinmaxwell equations in general relativity can be completely characterized by only three externally observable classical parameters. Testing the nohair theorem with observations of black. Jun 23, 2019 birkhoffs theorem is similar to a set of theorems called nohair theorems describing black holes.
Nohair theorems and black holes with hair 1 introduction. Inflation in bianchi models and the cosmic no hair theorem. A simple proof of a nohair theorem in einsteinhiggs theory. We have investigated cosmic nohair theorem with varying cosmological constant. Just call it baldy fresh analysis of ligo data supports no hair theorem for black holes ringdown overtones yield accurate estimates of mass and spin of a new black hole.
The nohair theorem states that all black hole solutions of the einsteinmaxwell equations of gravitation and electromagnetism in general relativity can be completely characterized by only three externally observable classical parameters. The approach is formulated in terms of a kerrlike spacetime that depends on a free parameter and is regular everywhere outside of the event horizon. No hair theorem in quasidilaton massive gravity sciencedirect. Hairy black holes with spherical symmetry seem to be easily constructed with a positive gaussbonnet gb coefficient. See also 17 for a scalar no hair theorem in stationary asymptotically. This is a test of the nohair theorem based purely on the postinspiral regime. This pro vides a free source of useful theorems, courtesy of reynolds abstraction theorem for the p olymorphic lam b. May 27, 2011 the no hair theorem characterizes the fundamental nature of black holes in general relativity. The nohair theorem relies on the cosmic censorship conjecture 38 as well as on the physically reasonable assumption that the exterior metric is free of closed timelike curves. In this paper, the cosmic no hair theorem for anisotropic bianchi models which admit inflation with a scalar field is studied in the framework of brane world. In this document, we prove the existence and unicity up to a positive constant multiple of the left haar measure and the right haar measure on a locally compact topological group.
Lack of such parameters means breaking of the conservations laws for a black hole. The nohair theorem was extended by robinson to the case where there is an electromagnetic field. Here we will show the same finetuning and no hair theorem apply to this generalization. Pdf the cosmic nohair theorem and the nonlinear stability. The no hair theorem says that black holes rapidly converge to a state that is completely described just by their mass, spin and charge. We show that when the quantum state of inflation is picked to ensure the validity of the eft. These are counterexamples to the expectation that powerlaw inflationary models obey a nohair theorem and all approach the flat friedman universe with a t oc t 231 as t oo. The nohair theorem characterizes the fundamental nature of black holes in general relativity. This theorem can be tested observationally by measuring the mass and spin of a black hole as well as its quadrupole moment, which may deviate from the expected kerr value. No hair theorems for stationary axisymmetric black holes. Inflation in bianchi models and the cosmic no hair theorem in. Several parametric deviations from the kerr metric have been suggested to study observational signatures in both the electromagnetic and gravitationalwave spectra that differ from the expected kerr signals. We model departures from general relativity gr by introducing extra parameters which change the mode frequencies or decay times from their values in gr. Sep 09, 2014 in general relativity this is known as the no hair theorem.
It is worth pointing out that the bekenstein black hole solution for a free scalar. This requirement, however, is in astrophysical realistic scenarios often violated, e. So no hair theorem says that stationarystationarys a key wordand asymptotically flatthis is also a key wordblack hole is fully characterized by the first, mass. It seems worth looking at the relationship between purely radiative spacetimes and no hair theorems in the vacuum case first.
According to the no hair theorem, astrophysical black holes are fully characterized by their masses and spins and are described by the kerr metric. Radiative einsteinmaxwell spacetimes and no hair theorems. The nohair theorem states that all black hole solutions of the einsteinmaxwell equations of. Various methods including scaling techniques, arguments based on energy conditions, conformal. Nohair theorems and blac k holes with hair by markus. We provide a rigorous mathematical proof on no hair theorem for.
There is still no rigorous mathematical proof of a general nohair theorem. In the following we shall give a proof of the nohair theorems for scalar and procamassive vector. According to the nohair theorem, static black holes are described by a schwarzschild spacetime provided there are no other sources of the gravitational field. No hair theorem in quasidilaton massive gravityjournal. Probable theorem chapter 15 residentanchor sanders. B nonexistence of particlelike solutions in field models with v. See the history of this page for a list of all contributions to it. Power law inflation and the cosmic no hair theorem in brane.
Nohair theorem for black holes in astrophysical environments. Teaching resources tap into teacher guides loaded with lessons and project ideas, as well as tips and tricks for handling helicopter parents and inspiring unruly children. Hong and motoo suzuki and masaki yamada, year2020 jeongpyong hong, 2 motoo suzuki, and masaki yamada 5, 6 center for theoretical physics of the universe, institute for basic science ibs. The cosmic no hair theorem is studied in anisotropic bianchi brane models which admit power law inflation with a scalar field. The name is chosen by analogy to black hole no hair theorems. Some new results are described, and various unsatisfactory features of the present theory are stressed. See also 17 for a scalar nohair theorem in stationary asymptotically. The nohair theorem 5 what we will see later is that in string theory, the assumptions made in the classical nohair theorems turn out to be violated in string theory. Mass and spin are the first two multipole moments of the kerr spacetime and completely determine all other moments. Nohair theorems and blac k holes with hair by markus heusler. All other information for which hair is a metaphor about the matter which formed a black.
They are members of a family of metrics found for other equations of state by wainwright and goode 28 and have r no dipole hair theorem for higherdimensional static black. As i understand it in information theoretic terms the black hole entropy is 1 bit per planck unit of area, which should then be the amount. Remind students of the video messages they heard that there is no such thing as a math brain or a math person. Later, we will see how nonperturbative effects in string theory violate the nohair theorems, and allow a resolution of the information paradox. It is shown that if the initial data, for an expanding cosmological model of this type, is subjected to a small perturbation then the corresponding solution exists globally in the future and the perturbation decays in a way. Testing the nohair theorem with gw150914 physics forums.
Virgil watched the two of them softly talking to one another before he sighed and covered his face. All other information for which hair is a metaphor about. In a recent paper, hod started a study on no scalar hair theorem for asymptotically. The nohair theorem has not been proved for the yangmills field, but the only difference seems to be the addition of one or more integers that label a discrete family of unstable solutions. The basic idea of the no hair theorem is that the material properties of any object referred to as hair because a physicist named.
Note that this true for all evendimensional spheres, and. Anyone can learn any level of math with hard work and effort. Originally nohair theorems meant theorems of uniqueness of the kerr. No hair theorem for weak pulsar andrei gruzinov ccpp, physics department, new york university, 4 washington place, new york, ny 3 it is proposed that there exists a class of pulsars, called weak pulsars, for which the largescale magnetosphere, and hence the gammaray emission, are independent of the detailed pattern of plasma production. Consequently, the nohair theorem can be tested by measuring at least three multipole moments of such a spacetime ryan 1995.
This implies that whenever we try to comb our pets, if they have hair on every points on surface, then there will always be at least one tuft of hair at one point on the ball. The nohair theorem establishes the remarkable property of generalrelativistic black holes that their spacetimes and hence all of their characteristics are uniquely determined by precisely three parameters. The spacetimes of such black holes are described by the. Fresh analysis of ligo data supports no hair theorem for. Thus, an advantage will be that our nohair theorem applies as well to metric fr models that cannot be mapped to scalartensor theory. Sgr a, the supermassive black hole at the center of the milky way, is a prime candidate for such tests. Springer nature is making sarscov2 and covid19 research free. A recent paper analyzing ligo data suggests though not conclusively that the nohair theorem likely holds, with implication for the information paradox and i was wondering where a confirmed nohair outcome leaves us with regards going beyond the standard model. Performing tests of the nohair theorem with observations of phenomena that occur in the vicinity of the circular photon orbit or the isco around a black holes requires that we use a metric that is free of such patholo. The validity of the cosmic no hair theorem is investigated in the context of newtonian cosmology with a perfect fluid matter model and a positive cosmological constant. At the centre of the uniqueness problem lies the proof that the static electrovacuum electrovac black hole space times with no degenerate horizon are described by the reissnernordstrom rn metric, whereas the.
The nohair theorem states that any isolated static black hole is necessarily a schwarzschild black hole and that there is only one free parameter describing the spacetimethe mass m. The no hair theorem postulates that all black hole solutions of the einsteinmaxwell equations of gravitation and electromagnetism in general relativity can be completely characterized by only three externally observable classical parameters. The no hair theorem says that a black hole can be characterized by a small number of parameters that are visible from distance mass, angular momentum and electric charge for me it is puzzling why local quantities are not included, i. Even if we restrict our thinking to matter and ordinary interactions, there could be lots of different black holes. The no hair theorem characterizes the fundamental nature of black holes in general relativity. A nohair theorem for black holes in fr gravity iopscience. The novelty is that this nohair theorem is built without resorting to known mapping between fr gravity and scalartensor theory. Birkhoffs theorem has a somewhat different structure than those of the nohair theorems, since it assumes a symmetry and proves the existence of an event horizon if the vacuum region is extended to small enough radii, whereas the nohair theorems assume an event horizon and prove the form of the metric, including its symmetries. S2 is not a lie group university of california, berkeley. Generalized quasidilaton massive gravity has been shown to have stable homogeneous and isotropic solutions, making it more appealing for cosmological applications, at least at a practical level. Testing the nohair theorem with observations in the. The uniqueness theorem for the no hair theorems, the uniqueness theorem is essential.
The most general nohair theorem states that a black hole is completely characterized by its mass, charge, and angular momentum. All black hole solutions of the einsteinmaxwell equations can be characterized by mass, electric charge, and angular momentum. The black hole solutions, which invoke new classical hairs for the black holes, may be counterexamples of the no hair theorem. This theorem can be tested observationally by measuring at least three different multipole moments of the spacetimes of black holes. The following results generalize those known in four dimensions. This theorem can be tested observationally by measuring the mass and spin of a black hole as well as. Citeseerx no hair theorems folklore, conjectures, results. The coupled system of gravity and mappings m,gn,g with harmonic action and additional potential is considered. This pap er is an extended v ersion of an in vited lecture held at the journ ees r elativistes 96.
According to the generalrelativistic nohair theorem, astrophysical black holes depend only on their masses and spins and are uniquely described by the kerr metric. Extension to generalized quasidilaton massive gravity. A simple proof of a nohair theorem in einsteinhiggs. Bayesian model selection for testing the nohair theorem with. In general relativity this is known as the nohair theorem. Nohair theorems and introduction to hairy black holes imperial. In the following we shall give a proof of the no hair theorems for scalar and procamassive vector. Expanded evasion of the black hole nohair theorem in. According to quantum theory, physical information is never lost, but according to general relativity and the nohair theorem, physical information that enters a black hole is lost forever. Examples of applications of our no hair theorem are presented in section 3, while we conclude this paper in section 4. This theorem says that the schwarzschild metric 2m 2 dr2 ds2.
1216 426 1223 716 1045 1535 184 714 77 706 357 224 43 1430 1553 792 304 72 1198 1438 694 1351 918 1513 1510 1099 241 1608 450 1184 1461 175 1215 230 587 1031 1255 164 1371 920 516 1163 449